Showing posts with label Death Row. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Death Row. Show all posts

Tuesday, April 5, 2011

Inmate in Texas challenges death penalty based on new drug

Cleve Foster, a convicted murderer on Texas' death row, is challenging the state's switch to a new drug for executions in light of the growing shortage of sodium thiopental, the New York Times reports today. Foster was convicted in 2004 of murdering a Sudanese woman with his roommate, who died in prison last year.

The Supreme Court has issued a stay of execution, also according to the Times, based on questions about counsel in addition to the questions about the legality of his execution.

However, what most interests me is the effect of a ruling against the use of alternative drugs in the execution of criminals:
As recently as January, 34 of the 35 states that allow lethal injections for executions used sodium thiopental, usually administered as the first of three drugs that are intended to prevent pain, inhibit muscle movement and then stop the heart.

Michelle Lyons, a spokeswoman for the Texas Department of Criminal Justice, said Monday that Mr. Foster’s execution was one of seven scheduled in Texas through August.

Ms. Lyons said that the state had plenty of sodium thiopental on hand, but that it reached its expiration date at the end of March.

Ms. Levin said Monday that Texas had failed to adhere to its own administrative rules when it decided to switch to pentobarbital and that it had not properly notified the public of the change.

Mr. Foster’s lawyers also say the state used an invalid federal permit to buy pentobarbital.

“Given the frequency of which we carry out this ultimate act, it should be done in compliance with the law, with transparency and deliberateness and care,” said Ms. Levin, who also teaches at the University of Texas. “It is experimental, a drug that is brand new to lethal injections.”

What do you guys think? Will the Supreme Court rule in Foster's favor? - and better yet, should they?

Sunday, February 27, 2011

False Confessions and DNA: A case from Texas

When watching reruns of 48 Hours Investigates this weekend, I came across an episode which had remarkable similarities to the WM3 case (video posted at bottom of post!). In this case, two young men confessed two the heinous murders of four teenage girls. But DNA proved that the confessions were false and the product of police pressure. After nearly 10 years in prison, Robert Springsteen, who had been on death row for the crime, and Robert Scott were released from prison. The charges against them were eventually dropped.

While this in itself is remarkable, what was said during the telecast about false confessions reiterates what we've been hearing about false confessions:

It's still so hard to believe - even when you look at someone in the eye - even when he says that there was so much pressure to confess - it's still hard to understand why a normal guy who's in his mid-20s could be coerced into admitting something that horrific.

"48 Hours" collected sections of defendant Michael Scott’s confessions and showed them to Saul Kassin, distinguished professor of psychology at John Jay College of Criminal Justice.

Kassin was familiar with the case because he was once contacted by the defense.

Scott: I remember looking at this girl. I hear the gun go off. I only pulled the trigger once… I hear somebody get slapped.

"A good valid confession will look something just like this. But there are many false confessions that are known, proven false confessions, that also look just like this," Kassin explained.

According to Kassin, the problem is what you see on tape is just a fraction of the actual interview.

"You can't tell just by looking," he said.

I asked him, "But why would somebody confess to something they didn't do? What goes on in a person’s mind to say, 'Yeah, I was there. I was thinking this?'"

"One is, the person feels absolutely trapped," Kassin explained.

Detective: At some point, Maurice hands you that revolver. What does he say to you?


"The goal of interrogation, very explicitly, is to increase the anxiety associated with denial," Kassin said.

Detective: Let’s do it now. You went inside with those boys, didn’t you Michael?


"We know you did it. And we don't want to hear any lies," said Kassin.

Watch the episode below.

Wednesday, February 2, 2011

Killing on Technicalities

Mara Leveritt wrote a great piece for the Arkansas Times about cases of applying the death penalty:

Read the article here.

I definitely agree with her position here. If an argument about the meaning of the word "all" is the only reason someone is still on death row (as the attorney general's office argued in Sept. at Damien's hearing), maybe we need a closer look at we're doing.

Tuesday, January 18, 2011

CNN Special: "Presumed Guilty: Murder in West Memphis"

Here's the links to the CNN content on the WM3 special which aired this weekend. It was quite sensationalized, but it definitely should get people interested in the case.


Here's a video clip from the special:






Here's the written story:

Death Row Inmate Could Get Second Chance


One of the things I found the most interesting about the special was that in her interview, Pam Hobbs, mother of victim Steve Branch and wife to Terry Hobbs, whom a lot of WM3 supporters think actually killed the boys, did not implicate him. She very carefully sidestepped the questions about his guilt, saying that she would be horrified if it ever came out that he was guilty. She said she could not imagine having lived with him for so long and then finding out he did this. It was interesting because so many people (activists) are so quick to blame him, but we haven't heard the same sentiments from people that knew him the best at that time.

Thursday, December 2, 2010

Death Penalty Article - "Innocence Must Matter"


I came across a Time article from May which raises important questions and previews a case which could have striking effects on the West Memphis 3 case and other death penalty cases around the nation.
DNA has played an important part in this case - and the right to enter DNA in appeals is an interesting question.

Click the link below to see the full article:
In Death-Penalty Cases, Innocence Has to Matter

Picture and article from Time.com

Wednesday, November 24, 2010

Damien Echols Interview on Memphis FOX-13

Here is the two-part FOX-13 interview with Damien Echols. It's a fairly interesting piece, though it contains at least one noticeable error: The reports says that Damien and Lorri Davis have been married for "15 years." They've actually been married for about 10 years, since December 1999.